I am a strong supporter of the State of Israel. At the same time, I do not particularly like her current government. Binyamin (Benjamin) Netanyahu is letting himself be held hostage by the extremists in his own government, particularly by Avigdor Lieberman and Yisrael Beiteinu and Eli Yishai and Shas. Netanyahu has had several opportunities to remove both men and their parties from the government and replace it with the Tzipi Livni-led Kadima. However, Netanyahu has refused to do so, and in the process has harmed Israel's interests by helping kill the recently-restrated peace process.
Of course, in this Netanyahu does not share sole blame. Mahmoud Abbas shoulders a fair share of the blame as well. Abbas is the one that refused to return to the negotiating table during the first nine months of the settlement freeze. Abbas is also the one that said Palestinians would never recognize Israel as a Jewish State and would never compromise on their core issues, including the right of return and a border adhering to the 1949 Armistice Lines with no land swaps.
The latter would mean giving up Israeli sovereignty over the Kotel (Western Wall) and recognizing Palestinian sovereignty. That is unacceptable and a clear indication that Abbas is not serious about peace. The Kotel is the holiest place in the world for our people. To force Israel to recognize foreign sovereignty over it now that it is under Israeli sovereignty is akin to asking Muslims to give up Mecca or Catholics to give up the Vatican combined with asking Britain to recognize foreign sovereignty over London or France to recognize foreign sovereignty over Paris.
Throughout its history Israel has fought several wars for its very existence, starting in 1948, when an Arab coalition attacked the newly-established state as it declared independence. Then, after Israel won its War of Independence, rather than sign peace treaties with Israel the Arab governments simply left the armistice in place. It was not until 1979 that an Arab country (Egypt) signed a peace treaty with Israel. It was then another fifteen years until another Arab country (Jordan) signed a peace treaty with Israel. To date, Egypt and Jordan are the only Arab countries at peace with Israel and with full diplomatic relations with Israel.
People must understand that Israel is the historical homeland of the Jewish People. It was where my ancestors came from before they found themselves in Latvia and Poland. It was in Israel that we were forged as a nation. And that legacy continues on today, not only in the modern State of Israel, but also in the fact that as an Ashkenazi Jew my genetic relationship with Sephardi and Mizrachi Jews are ten times closer than any of us are related to the host populations our ancestors lived among in Europe, North Africa, the Levant and Iran.
Most importantly, today I am in exile, in the Diaspora, because that is my choice. I hold only American citizenship and live in the United States because that is my choice. At any time I remain free to pack my bags and return to my ancestral homeland. That is something that was denied to the overwhelming majority of my fellow Jews for nearly 2,000 years. It is for that reason that Israel is so important for me.
Finally, I believe that Zionism can very easily be distilled into the sixth and seventh lines in Hatikvah, Israel's national anthem:
התקוה בת שנות אלפים
להיות עם חפשי בארצנו
The Hope of 2,000 years
To be a free people in our land